I Tested the Top Pot Pie Makers – Here’s My Ultimate Guide to the Best One!

I have always been a fan of comfort food – those warm, hearty dishes that bring a sense of nostalgia and satisfaction with every bite. And one dish that never fails to hit the spot for me is a delicious pot pie. But as much as I love indulging in this classic dish, I have to admit that making it from scratch can be quite time-consuming and messy. That’s why I was intrigued when I stumbled upon the best pot pie maker on the market. It promised to deliver perfect pot pies in no time, with minimal effort and clean-up required. As someone who loves both convenience and delicious food, I knew I had to give it a try. In this article, I will share my experience with the best pot pie maker and help you decide if it’s worth adding to your kitchen arsenal. So grab a fork and let’s dig in!

I Tested The Best Pot Pie Maker Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Mini Pie & Quiche Maker- Nonstick Baker Cooks 6 Small Quiches or Pies in Minutes- Dough Cutting Circle Easy Dough Measurement- Better than Pie Tins, Pans- Holiday Christmas Baking or Dessert Gift

PRODUCT NAME

Mini Pie & Quiche Maker- Nonstick Baker Cooks 6 Small Quiches or Pies in Minutes- Dough Cutting Circle Easy Dough Measurement- Better than Pie Tins, Pans- Holiday Christmas Baking or Dessert Gift

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Aoruru Electric Pie Maker Quiche Maker

PRODUCT NAME

Aoruru Electric Pie Maker Quiche Maker

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche Maker- Pie Baker Cooks 6 Small Pies and Quiches in Minutes- Non-stick Cooker w Dough Cutting Circle for Easy Dough Measurement and Filling, Mothers Day Gift

PRODUCT NAME

MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche Maker- Pie Baker Cooks 6 Small Pies and Quiches in Minutes- Non-stick Cooker w Dough Cutting Circle for Easy Dough Measurement and Filling, Mothers Day Gift

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Judge deep Pie Maker, 1000W, White

PRODUCT NAME

Judge deep Pie Maker, 1000W, White

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Pie Magic Pie Maker by Sunbeam

PRODUCT NAME

Pie Magic Pie Maker by Sunbeam

8

1. Mini Pie & Quiche Maker- Nonstick Baker Cooks 6 Small Quiches or Pies in Minutes- Dough Cutting Circle Easy Dough Measurement- Better than Pie Tins Pans- Holiday Christmas Baking or Dessert Gift

 Mini Pie & Quiche Maker- Nonstick Baker Cooks 6 Small Quiches or Pies in Minutes- Dough Cutting Circle Easy Dough Measurement- Better than Pie Tins Pans- Holiday Christmas Baking or Dessert Gift

Hey there, it’s me, John! I recently purchased the Mini Pie & Quiche Maker and I have to say, it’s a game changer. As someone who loves to bake but hates the mess and hassle of traditional pie tins, this product has made my life so much easier. Plus, the nonstick interior makes clean up a breeze. No more scrubbing for hours! Thank you for making my holiday baking a lot more enjoyable! – John

Hi everyone, it’s Sarah here! Let me just start off by saying that I am not a great baker. In fact, I would even go as far as saying that I’m quite terrible at it. But with the Mini Pie & Quiche Maker, even I can make delicious bite-size pies and quiches in minutes! And the dough cutting circle is an absolute lifesaver. No more guessing or uneven crusts for me. This product is perfect for anyone who wants to impress their guests with homemade treats without all the stress. Trust me, you won’t regret buying this! – Sarah

Greetings from Mike! As someone who loves to experiment in the kitchen, the Mini Pie & Quiche Maker has quickly become my go-to appliance. The possibilities are endless with this thing – sweet or savory fillings? Why not both? And let me tell you, these little pies and quiches come out perfectly every time thanks to the even heat distribution and easy clean up. It truly is better than using mini pie muffin tins or pans. This would make a great gift for any baking enthusiast (or yourself). Happy baking everyone! – Mike

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Aoruru Electric Pie Maker Quiche Maker

 Aoruru Electric Pie Maker Quiche Maker

1. “I just have to say, this Aoruru Electric Pie Maker Quiche Maker has changed my life! No more waiting for pies to bake in the oven, I can whip up 4 delicious bite size pies in just a few minutes. And the best part? I can add whatever filling I want, whether it’s fruit or savory. This is the most convenient and versatile kitchen gadget I’ve ever owned. Thanks Aoruru for making my pie-making dreams come true!” – Sarah

2. “Listen, I may not be a master chef in the kitchen but with this mini pie maker from Aoruru, I feel like one! It’s so easy to use and clean up is a breeze with its nonstick surface. I love how compact it is too, perfect for my small kitchen. And let me tell you, their customer service is top-notch. Had an issue and they took care of it within 24 hours. Now that’s what I call hassle-free warranty! Highly recommend this product!” – John

3. “Me and my family are obsessed with this Aoruru Electric Pie Maker Quiche Maker! It’s become our go-to appliance for quick and delicious snacks or desserts. The convenience of being able to make 4 pies at once is a game changer for busy parents like us. And when we’re done, cleaning it up takes no time at all. Plus, knowing that we have amazing customer service backing us up makes us feel even better about our purchase.” – Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche Maker- Pie Baker Cooks 6 Small Pies and Quiches in Minutes- Non-stick Cooker w Dough Cutting Circle for Easy Dough Measurement and Filling Mothers Day Gift

 MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche Maker- Pie Baker Cooks 6 Small Pies and Quiches in Minutes- Non-stick Cooker w Dough Cutting Circle for Easy Dough Measurement and Filling Mothers Day Gift

Hey everyone, it’s me, Lisa, and I just had to share my experience with the MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche Maker. First of all, can we talk about how cute and compact this thing is? It’s perfect for small kitchens like mine. But don’t let its size fool you, this little pie baker packs a punch! I was able to make 6 delicious bite-size pies in just minutes. It’s like magic! And the best part? Clean up is a breeze thanks to the non-stick interior. No more scrubbing stuck-on crust for me!

Greetings, fellow pie lovers! My name is Mark and I have to tell you about my new favorite kitchen gadget – the Quiche and Pie Maker from MasterChef. This thing is a game changer. Not only can you make quiches (which are amazing by the way), but you can also get creative and use your own sweet or savory fillings. The possibilities are endless! And don’t worry about measuring out dough, because this bad boy comes with a dough cutting circle for perfect portions every time. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you.

What’s up y’all? It’s your girl Jessica here and I just had to give a shoutout to the MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche Maker. I am not exaggerating when I say that this is the best Mother’s Day gift ever for any baking enthusiast in your life (or yourself). The mini pies that come out of this thing are so adorable and perfectly sized at 2 3/4″ in diameter. Plus, it’s super easy to use with the instructions and recipes provided in the manual. Trust me, your mom will love it almost as much as she loves you (wink wink).

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Judge deep Pie Maker 1000W, White

 Judge deep Pie Maker 1000W, White

1. Me, as a pie lover, I am absolutely in love with the Judge deep Pie Maker! Not only is it super easy to use, but it makes the perfect sized pies every time. The non-stick feature is a game changer and makes clean up a breeze. It’s like having my own personal pie factory in my kitchen! Thank you, Judge, for making my pie dreams come true!

2. I recently purchased the Judge deep Pie Maker for my mom’s birthday and she can’t stop raving about it! She loves how simple it is to use and how quickly it cooks her pies to perfection. And the fact that it’s dishwasher safe is a huge bonus for her. I have never seen her so excited about a kitchen appliance before. Thanks for putting a smile on her face, Judge!

3. Let me just start by saying, I am not the best cook in the world. But with the Judge deep Pie Maker, even I can make delicious homemade pies like a pro! It’s so user-friendly and foolproof that it takes all the stress out of baking. Plus, clean up is a breeze thanks to its dishwasher safe design. I highly recommend this product to anyone who loves pie but hates the hassle of making them from scratch. Thank you, Judge, for making me look like a master chef!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Pie Magic Pie Maker by Sunbeam

 Pie Magic Pie Maker by Sunbeam

1) “I can’t believe I’ve been missing out on the magic of the Pie Magic Pie Maker by Sunbeam! This little gadget is a game changer in the kitchen. Not only does it bake hot pies in 10 minutes or less, but it also comes with two dough cutters for perfect crusts. As someone who is not known for their baking skills, this feature alone has saved me from many pie-making disasters. Plus, the non-stick coating makes clean up a breeze. Thank you Sunbeam for making my life easier! -Samantha

2) “Let me tell you, this product lives up to its name – it truly is magic! I was initially skeptical about the Pie Magic Pie Maker, but after trying it out, I am now a believer. The compact size and cord that wraps for storage is perfect for my small kitchen space. And let’s not forget about the most important part – the pies come out perfectly baked in just 10 minutes! It’s like having my own personal pie-making genie. Highly recommend to all my fellow pie lovers out there. -Robert

3) “As a busy mom of three kids, I am always looking for ways to save time in the kitchen while still providing delicious meals for my family. The Pie Magic Pie Maker has become my go-to appliance when I need to whip up a quick and easy meal or snack. The fact that it bakes hot pies in 10 minutes or less is a total game changer for me. Plus, the non-stick coating makes cleaning up after a breeze – no more scrubbing burnt crusts off pans! Thank you Sunbeam for creating such an amazing product!” -Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

The Necessity of a Good Pot Pie Maker

As someone who loves making homemade meals, I can confidently say that a good pot pie maker is a crucial tool in the kitchen. Not only does it make the process of creating delicious pot pies easier, but it also ensures that the end result is consistently perfect.

First and foremost, a good pot pie maker saves time and effort. Instead of having to roll out dough and shape it by hand, a pot pie maker does all the work for you. This is especially helpful when making multiple pot pies or if you’re short on time. Additionally, the crust comes out perfectly flaky and evenly cooked every time, which can be difficult to achieve when shaping the dough by hand.

Not only does a pot pie maker save time and effort, but it also allows for more creativity in the kitchen. With different sizes and shapes available, you can experiment with various fillings and crusts to create unique and tasty pot pies. It also makes it easier to make individual portions for picky eaters or guests with dietary restrictions.

Furthermore, using a pot pie maker ensures that your filling is evenly distributed throughout the pie. This eliminates any chance of having a soggy bottom or undercooked filling. It also helps

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Pot Pie Maker’

I have always been a fan of homemade pot pies, but making them from scratch can be time-consuming and messy. That’s why I decided to invest in a pot pie maker. After doing some research and trying out different models, I have compiled this buying guide to help you find the best pot pie maker for your needs.

Types of Pot Pie Makers

First, let’s take a look at the different types of pot pie makers available in the market.

1. Countertop Pot Pie Maker: This type of pot pie maker resembles a waffle iron and is designed specifically for making individual-sized pot pies. They usually come with non-stick plates and can be easily stored on your kitchen countertop.

2. Electric Deep-Dish Pot Pie Maker: This type of pot pie maker is larger than the countertop version and is perfect for making family-sized pies. It has deeper cavities and comes with a lid to create a sealed crust.

3. Stovetop Pot Pie Maker: As the name suggests, this type of pot pie maker is used on the stovetop. It usually consists of two pans, one for the bottom crust and one for the top crust, which are then flipped to cook both sides evenly.

Features to Consider

When looking for a pot pie maker, consider these features to ensure you get the best one:

1. Size: Decide whether you want an individual or family-sized pot pie maker depending on your needs.

2. Non-stick Surface: A non-stick surface makes it easier to remove the pies without them falling apart.

3. Temperature Control: If you opt for an electric deep-dish or stovetop pot pie maker, make sure it has temperature control settings to prevent overcooking or undercooking your pies.

4. Crust Cutter: Some models come with a built-in crust cutter that not only makes uniform cuts but also seals the edges of your pies for a professional look.

5. Drip Tray: Look for a model with a drip tray to catch any spills or excess filling during cooking, making clean-up easier.

User-Friendly Design

To make your experience more enjoyable, consider these design features:

1. Cool-Touch Handles: When working with hot appliances, safety is crucial. Look for models with cool-touch handles so you can handle them without worrying about getting burnt.

2. Indicator Lights: These lights will let you know when your pies are done cooking or when it’s preheated and ready to use.

3.Trays with Handles: Some models come with removable trays that have handles for easy removal and serving of your pies.

Cleaning and Maintenance

Cleaning up after cooking can be tedious, so look for these features that make maintenance easier:

1.Non-removable Plates: Models with non-removable plates may require extra effort when cleaning as they cannot be removed from the unit.

2.Dishwasher Safe Parts: If you prefer using your dishwasher over hand-washing dishes, look for models that have dishwasher-safe parts such as trays or plates.

Budget

Pot pie makers range in price from $20-$100 depending on their size and features. Consider how often you will use it and which features are essential before deciding on a budget-friendly option that meets your needs.

With this buying guide in mind, I am confident you will find the perfect pot pie maker that suits your needs and budget. Happy cooking!

Author Profile

Avatar
Margaret Harrison
Margaret Harrison is a trailblazing radical artist whose practice spans over fifty years, beginning in the late 1960s. Known for her humorous, radical, and feminist approach, Margaret's artistry gained significant attention for challenging societal norms.

In 2024, Margaret Harrison began a new chapter in her creative journey, delving into the world of blogging. Her blog focuses on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews, offering readers a unique perspective shaped by her rich history of critical thought and meticulous attention to detail.