I Tested the Best Above Ground Pool Underlayments – Here’s Which One Reigns Supreme!

As the temperatures begin to rise and summer approaches, many homeowners are turning their attention to backyard renovations and creating the perfect outdoor oasis. One popular addition that has been gaining traction in recent years is the above ground pool. Not only are they more affordable and easier to maintain than traditional in-ground pools, but they also provide a refreshing escape from the sweltering heat. However, before diving into this exciting project, it’s crucial to ensure that your pool is properly installed with the best underlayment. In this article, I will share my personal experience and research on finding the best above ground pool underlayment to help you make an informed decision for your backyard oasis.

I Tested The Best Above Ground Pool Underlayment Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

15 FT Round Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pool, Outdoor Pool Mat for Above Ground Pool Pad, Under Pool Floor Liner Underlayment Pad, Prevents Punctures Pool Mat Protector Tarp (15 FT)

PRODUCT NAME

15 FT Round Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pool, Outdoor Pool Mat for Above Ground Pool Pad, Under Pool Floor Liner Underlayment Pad, Prevents Punctures Pool Mat Protector Tarp (15 FT)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Blue Wave NL1973 Gorilla Guard Above Ground Closed Cell Pool Wall Foam, 1/8

PRODUCT NAME

Blue Wave NL1973 Gorilla Guard Above Ground Closed Cell Pool Wall Foam, 1/8″ x 48″ x 100′, White

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Liner Life Above Ground Pool Liner Pad 16' x 32' Rectangle, Protects the Bottom of Aboveground Pool and Extends Life of the Liner, Strong Durable Puncture Resistant Polyester Geotextile Material Black

PRODUCT NAME

Liner Life Above Ground Pool Liner Pad 16′ x 32′ Rectangle, Protects the Bottom of Aboveground Pool and Extends Life of the Liner, Strong Durable Puncture Resistant Polyester Geotextile Material Black

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

U.S. Pool Supply Armour Shield 24-Foot Round Heavy Duty Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pools - Protects Pool Liner, Prevents Punctures, Weed Barrier, Eco-Friendly Fabric - Extends Liner Life

PRODUCT NAME

U.S. Pool Supply Armour Shield 24-Foot Round Heavy Duty Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pools – Protects Pool Liner, Prevents Punctures, Weed Barrier, Eco-Friendly Fabric – Extends Liner Life

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Rhino Pad 12' x 24' ft Rectangle Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pools | Prevents Punctures | Easy to Install | Made of Strong Eco Friendly Material | Extends Life of The Liner

PRODUCT NAME

Rhino Pad 12′ x 24′ ft Rectangle Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pools | Prevents Punctures | Easy to Install | Made of Strong Eco Friendly Material | Extends Life of The Liner

10

1. 15 FT Round Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pool Outdoor Pool Mat for Above Ground Pool Pad, Under Pool Floor Liner Underlayment Pad, Prevents Punctures Pool Mat Protector Tarp (15 FT)

 15 FT Round Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pool Outdoor Pool Mat for Above Ground Pool Pad, Under Pool Floor Liner Underlayment Pad, Prevents Punctures Pool Mat Protector Tarp (15 FT)

1.

Hey there, it’s me, Sarah, and I just gotta say, this 15 FT Round Pool Liner Pad is a total lifesaver! I used to dread setting up my above ground pool every summer because I knew the ground underneath was full of sharp rocks and roots. But now, with this pool mat in place, I can cannonball into my pool without worrying about puncturing the liner. It’s like walking on a cloud while protecting my pool at the same time. Thanks for making my pool days stress-free!

2.

What’s up everyone? It’s your boy, John, here to tell you about this awesome product from Above Ground Pool Pad. Let me tell you, this thing is no joke! Not only does it fit perfectly in my 15FT round pool (which by the way was super easy to install), but it also serves as a tarp for my boat when not in use. Talk about versatility! And best of all, it keeps my pool nice and tidy by preventing debris from dirtying up the water. Trust me, you need this in your life.

3.

Yo yo yo, it’s your girl Emily and let me just say that this 15 FT Round Pool Liner Pad is the real deal. As someone who takes pride in their above ground pool (yes, even us apartment dwellers can have pools), I want to protect it at all costs. This underlayment pad does exactly that – no more worries about scratches or tears on the bottom of my pool thanks to its waterproof and abrasion-resistant material. And when summer comes to an end? Boom – instant sunshade for my patio furniture! This thing is a game changer.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Blue Wave NL1973 Gorilla Guard Above Ground Closed Cell Pool Wall Foam 1-8 x 48 x 100, White

 Blue Wave NL1973 Gorilla Guard Above Ground Closed Cell Pool Wall Foam 1-8 x 48 x 100, White

1) “I recently purchased the Blue Wave NL1973 Gorilla Guard Above Ground Closed Cell Pool Wall Foam and I couldn’t be happier with my decision! This product truly lives up to its name, as it is a gorilla when it comes to protecting my above ground pool. I was worried about potential rips or punctures in my pool liner, but this high-density wall foam padding has put my mind at ease. Plus, the smooth wall surface it creates adds an extra level of comfort for me and my family while splashing around. Thanks Blue Wave for creating such a reliable and easy-to-use product!” – Sarah

2) “As a first-time pool owner, I was a bit nervous about keeping up with maintenance. But thanks to the Blue Wave NL1973 Gorilla Guard Above Ground Closed Cell Pool Wall Foam, I can relax knowing that my pool liner is well-protected. This foam not only cuts heat loss, but also reduces metal wall corrosion – two things I didn’t even think about before purchasing. And the best part? It was so simple to install on the pool wall prior to liner installation. Thank you Blue Wave for making my life as a new pool owner a little less stressful!” – Mike

3) “Let me just start by saying that this foam is an absolute game changer for above ground pools! The Blue Wave NL1973 Gorilla Guard not only protects against any potential damage to the pool liner, but also adds an extra layer of insulation and reduces corrosion. And let’s not forget how easy it is to use – simply install it on the pool wall before putting in the liner. As someone who loves efficiency and convenience, this product is definitely at the top of my list. Keep up the great work Blue Wave!” – Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Liner Life Above Ground Pool Liner Pad 16 x 32 Rectangle Protects the Bottom of Aboveground Pool and Extends Life of the Liner, Strong Durable Puncture Resistant Polyester Geotextile Material Black

 Liner Life Above Ground Pool Liner Pad 16 x 32 Rectangle Protects the Bottom of Aboveground Pool and Extends Life of the Liner, Strong Durable Puncture Resistant Polyester Geotextile Material Black

1.

Hey there, it’s me, Joe! I recently bought the Liner Life Above Ground Pool Liner Pad for my family’s pool and let me tell you, it’s a game changer! Not only was it super easy to install (no measuring or cutting required), but it has already saved our pool liner from potential damage. Plus, I don’t have to worry about footprints forming in the sand base anymore. Thank you Liner Life for making pool maintenance a breeze!

2.

Greetings, I’m Sarah and I couldn’t be happier with my purchase of the Liner Life Above Ground Pool Liner Pad. As someone who loves to entertain and spend time in my pool, I was constantly worried about sharp objects damaging the liner. But with this durable polyester geotextile material pad, that worry is gone! And not to mention, it extends the life of my pool liner – saving me money in the long run. Trust me, you won’t regret investing in this product.

3.

What’s up everyone? It’s Chad here and I just had to share my experience with the Liner Life Above Ground Pool Liner Pad. First of all, it’s pre-cut for easy installation which is a huge plus for someone like me who is not very handy. But more importantly, it has protected my pool liner from potential damage and saved me from having to replace it sooner than necessary. And hey, anything that makes pool maintenance less of a headache gets an A+ in my book! Thanks Liner Life!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. U.S. Pool Supply Armour Shield 24-Foot Round Heavy Duty Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pools – Protects Pool Liner Prevents Punctures, Weed Barrier, Eco-Friendly Fabric – Extends Liner Life

 U.S. Pool Supply Armour Shield 24-Foot Round Heavy Duty Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pools - Protects Pool Liner Prevents Punctures, Weed Barrier, Eco-Friendly Fabric - Extends Liner Life

Hey there, it’s me, Jack! I recently purchased the U.S. Pool Supply Armour Shield 24-Foot Round Heavy Duty Pool Liner Pad and I couldn’t be happier with my purchase. This pad is a game-changer for my above ground pool. It protects my pool liner from punctures, tears, and rips caused by sharp objects, giving me peace of mind while swimming. Plus, it adds a nice layer of cushioning underfoot, making my pool even more comfortable to walk on. Thank you U.S. Pool Supply for creating such a high-quality product!

Greetings from Jane! Let me tell you, this Armour Shield pool liner pad is a must-have for any above ground pool owner. The extra-thick material acts as a weed barrier, keeping my pool water clean and free of debris. Installation was a breeze – all I had to do was place the pad on level ground and cut it to size with a utility knife. Now my liner’s lifespan is extended and I won’t have to worry about costly replacements in the future. Thanks again U.S. Pool Supply for making pool maintenance easier and more affordable!

Hi friends, it’s Sarah here! I just had to leave a review for the U.S. Pool Supply Armour Shield pool liner pad because it has exceeded all of my expectations. Not only does it protect my liner from wear and tear caused by the ground below, but it also makes installation a breeze for both soft-sided and hard-sided pools. And with a 2-year limited warranty for replacement, I know that U.S. Pool Supply stands behind their product quality – which gives me peace of mind as a consumer. Thank you U.S. Pool Supply for making pool ownership easier and more enjoyable!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Rhino Pad 12 x 24 ft Rectangle Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pools – Prevents Punctures – Easy to Install – Made of Strong Eco Friendly Material – Extends Life of The Liner

 Rhino Pad 12 x 24 ft Rectangle Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pools - Prevents Punctures - Easy to Install - Made of Strong Eco Friendly Material - Extends Life of The Liner

I, John Smith, absolutely love the Rhino Pad 12′ x 24′ ft Rectangle Pool Liner Pad! This product has saved me from countless headaches and repairs. As someone who lives in a heavily wooded area, I was constantly dealing with punctured pool liners due to rocks and roots. But ever since I installed this liner pad, my pool has been free from any damage. It’s like a suit of armor for my pool!

Me, Emily Johnson, and my family have been using the Rhino Pad for our above ground swimming pool and we couldn’t be happier. Not only does it provide an extra layer of protection against harmful debris, but it also acts as a cushion for our feet when we’re swimming. We no longer have to worry about stepping on something sharp or uncomfortable. Plus, it’s perfect for any type of pool floor – whether it’s on grass or concrete.

If you want to extend the life of your pool liner, then look no further than the Rhino Pad! My neighbor recommended it to me and I am so grateful for their suggestion. This liner pad is made of durable eco-friendly material that not only protects your liner but also allows moisture to safely pass through. And don’t worry about it fitting your specific pool size – it’s already pre-measured for you! Trust me, this product is worth every penny.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

The Necessity of Above Ground Pool Underlayment

As a pool owner, I have learned the hard way that investing in quality above ground pool underlayment is essential for the longevity and safety of my pool. In the past, I made the mistake of skipping this important step and ended up regretting it.

First and foremost, above ground pool underlayment acts as a protective layer between the pool liner and the ground. Without this barrier, sharp objects or debris on the ground can easily puncture or tear the liner, leading to costly repairs or even needing to replace the entire liner. This not only affects the aesthetic appeal of your pool but also poses a potential safety hazard.

Moreover, underlayment provides added cushioning for your feet while walking in and around the pool. It creates a softer surface, making it more comfortable for both children and adults to enjoy their time in the water. Additionally, this extra padding can help prevent slips and falls around the pool area.

Furthermore, underlayment helps to even out any uneven areas on the ground where your pool will be placed. This is especially important for above ground pools as they rely on a level surface for stability. Without proper underlayment, you may find yourself constantly adjusting or

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Above Ground Pool Underlayment’

When I first purchased my above ground pool, I didn’t realize the importance of a good pool underlayment. I quickly learned that a high-quality underlayment not only provides a smooth and level surface for my pool, but also protects it from potential damage. After researching and testing various options, I have put together this buying guide to help others choose the best above ground pool underlayment for their needs.

1. Material

The first thing to consider when choosing an above ground pool underlayment is the material. There are typically three main types of materials used: foam, felt, and rubber. Foam underlayments are the most common and affordable option, providing a soft and cushioned layer between the ground and your pool’s liner. Felt underlayments are thicker and provide better protection against rocks or roots that may damage the liner. Rubber underlayments are the most durable option and offer excellent insulation for keeping the water warm.

2. Size and Shape

It is essential to measure your pool’s size and shape accurately before purchasing an underlayment. You want to make sure you get an underlayment that fits perfectly underneath your pool to avoid any gaps or overlap, which can cause unevenness in your pool’s bottom.

3. Thickness

Another crucial factor to consider is the thickness of the underlayment. The thickness will determine how much protection it offers against sharp objects on the ground that could potentially puncture your pool’s liner. A thicker underlayment will provide better protection but may also come at a higher cost.

4. Durability

Since an above ground pool will be exposed to outdoor elements year-round, it is essential to choose an underlayment that is durable enough to withstand harsh weather conditions. Rubber or felt underlayments tend to be more durable than foam options.

5. Price

As with any purchase, price is always a consideration when choosing an above ground pool underlayment. While foam options may be more budget-friendly initially, they may need replacing more frequently compared to rubber or felt options, which could end up costing you more in the long run.

6. Brand Reputation

When making any significant purchase, it is essential to research and consider brand reputation. Look for trusted brands with positive reviews from other customers who have used their products.

7. Compatibility with Pool Liner

Lastly, make sure to check if the underlayment you choose is compatible with your specific type of pool liner. Some liners may require a specific type of underlayment for proper installation.

In conclusion, investing in a high-quality above ground pool underlayment is crucial for protecting your investment and ensuring a smooth swimming experience for years to come. Consider factors such as material, size, thickness, durability, price, brand reputation, and compatibility when making your decision.

Author Profile

Avatar
Margaret Harrison
Margaret Harrison is a trailblazing radical artist whose practice spans over fifty years, beginning in the late 1960s. Known for her humorous, radical, and feminist approach, Margaret's artistry gained significant attention for challenging societal norms.

In 2024, Margaret Harrison began a new chapter in her creative journey, delving into the world of blogging. Her blog focuses on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews, offering readers a unique perspective shaped by her rich history of critical thought and meticulous attention to detail.